The phones we use today nearly didn’t happen

The phones we use today nearly didn’t happen


It became a bumpy and undecided avenue to making the multipurpose telephones we spend this present day.

Angela Lang/CNET

This narrative is segment of CNET at 25, celebrating a quarter century of alternate tech and our role in telling you its narrative.

Every time you exhaust a smartphone, you are enjoying one thing we thought may perhaps perhaps by no manner exist: a tool that does nearly every little thing undoubtedly properly. Nonetheless within the early years after CNET’s founding in 1995, there became a bunch of debate about whether a single converged tool became imaginable, and even wanted. 

Even into the first decade of the 2000s, CNET talked to specialists who doubted that convergence became imaginable, asked “enact we in actuality favor our telephones to enact every little thing?” and flat out stated “convergence gadgets dismay me.” That can seem absurd this present day, however endure in thoughts that now not long ago a television handiest displayed television, a phone handiest made phone calls, cameras were apt that and handiest GPS gadgets had GPS.

For more Cell

Subscribe to the Cell publication, derive notifications and explore connected tales on CNET.

Then every little thing changed as PDAs, BlackBerrys after which smartphones with out note clicked. 

“We were bringing one thing contemporary into the arena in an air of secrecy of failure,” recalled Donna Dubinsky, veteran CEO of Palm, co-founder of Handspring and now CEO of machine intelligence firm Numenta. “The Apple Newton and Casio Zoomer had been a broad bust.”

PocketPC, Sony Magic Link and Apple Newton

PocketPC, Sony Magic Link and the Apple Newton were all early stops on the avenue to this present day’s elegantly converged phone. Nonetheless now not all of them caught on.

Brian Cooley/CNET

Tech luminaries portrayed the groundwork for converged tech with Jetsons-esque visions of what became imaginable. Compaq CEO Eckhard Pfeiffer predicted in 1997 that our properties would be wired, and in 2004 Microsoft CEO Invoice Gates forecast the trim dwelling and products and companies such as Netflix, two trends we now preserve as a true. At their time, those pronouncements generated explore rolls and debate as on the full as excessive consideration.

Nonetheless the dwelling net revolution happened. For folks who thought a dwelling computer became too scientific or nerdy, there were dwelling net terminals such as Compaq’s iPaq Home Web Equipment or WebTV and MSN Associate. From dwelling computing and the net came the idea that linked products and companies wants to be with us your total time.


Web TV, which later became MSN TV became on the full a product line of cheap computer programs with a month-to-month rating entry to rate thru a web service provider.


The Huge Bang: Classic Magic

Classic Magic became nearly the Huge Bang of tech convergence, constructing what can aloof be with out quandary is named the progenitor of the celebrated smartphone with loads of companions 20 years ahead of the iPad. It became launched all over the identical time because the clumsy Apple Newton, which Classic Magic killed. Released in 1994, the Magic Cap platform sought to combine the present PC and mobile phone in a conveyable bundle, however did now not enact so actually (Microsoft would are trying that later, with melancholy outcomes). Magic Cap gadgets from Sony and Motorola had a varied desktop interface, eschewing a T9 keyboard for a stylus-pushed touchscreen. They were designed to impart with another linked tool, despite platform. The prescience of these functions is outstanding this present day.  

Sony HIX-3000 and Magic Cap desktop

One of Sony’s gadgets in accordance with Classic Magic’s platform, and the desktop interface it aged. While rather paying homage to Microsoft Bob, it became a prescient step toward this present day’s smartphone. 

Josh Carter and Computer History Museum

Nonetheless Classic Magic had about a broad blind spots. It struggled with the rising net, shipping on time and funds, and bringing the market alongside with its vision.

“Or now not it is far never apt the expertise that wins, or now not it is far vital to create a undoubtedly absorbing product or service that of us can realize,” stated veteran Classic Magic engineer Tony Fadell. “And you wish marketing journey early on as you construct, now not later must you lunge to market.” Fadell would lunge on to lead constructing for the iPod and loads of the iPhone at Apple ahead of founding Nest after which turning into a main at tech advisory lab Future Form.


The Palm Pilot wasn’t the first PDA, however it became the first to construct it broad.

Palm went up to now as to recruit Donna Dubinsky’s mother, as properly as those of Palm founder Jeff Hawkins and marketing vp Ed Colligan to work the expose ground on the key Agenda expertise conference, the attach the Palm Pilot became launched, to underline their tool’s approachability.

Classic Magic outdated away in 2002 as Silicon Valley’s finest underdeveloped promise. Restful, as veteran employee Tom Hershenson says in a 2018 documentary about the firm, “Failure is now not the finish, or now not it is in actuality the muse.” Palm, Handspring, BlackBerry and Apple were all about to expose that.

Convergence in our purchase

Classic Magic became floundering all over the time CNET started, and our consideration naturally fell toward contemporary products, at the side of 3Com’s Palm Pilot. I endure in thoughts when it launched in 1996: At some point we were carrying nothing more sturdy than Motorola StarTACs, the following day we all had Palm Pilots.

Now enjoying:
Survey this:

Celebrating 25 years of CNET

3: 58

Brett Pearce/CNET

The Palm Pilot’s mixture of contacts, notes, calendar and a to-enact record wasn’t outlandish, however placing them in a little bundle with a reason-built handwriting interface and syncing to your PC with the push of a button became transformative. It converged vital apps with a more human interface and synchronization with the then-dominant laptop pc computer. “We had no idea how it would enact,” recalled Dubinksy. “Nonetheless after the first four or 5 months, the freeway apt went straight up.” And the joys came nearly fully on word of mouth from early adopters. 

In 2002 the Handspring Treo married the Palm Pilot with a mobile phone, wi-fi net data and a rudimentary apps universe. We had entered the era of power partial consideration and switch into aged to walking around having a gaze down at our telephones. Nonetheless we additionally realized that a tool may perhaps perhaps enact more the next day than it does this present day, attributable to its convergence with the mobile web. 

The BlackBerry had the company market sewn up, however the Treo became what you wished to raise: Pull it out on the dinner table with company and likewise you were icy. Attain the identical with your BlackBerry and likewise you had to apologize for being a slave to the web site of work.

Microsoft made a drag at both with pocket variations of Home windows that when it comes to place apart a stink on the full convergence theory. They evolved thru an unloved and confusing array of variations adore Home windows Cell, PocketPC and Home windows CE that were all an excessive amount of an dispute in ramming a PC into a little bundle.


5 years ahead of the iPhone, the Treo became the first to crack the code of converged personal gadgets.


“One of many broad breakthroughs in our pondering became the opinion that these gadgets wanted to be their have design middle,” Dubinsky stated. “They were now not apt smaller variations of greater things. Terrified a PC became out to be a unsuitable design idea.”

Compaq developed the ultimate of the unsuitable bunch with its once-sizzling iPaq line and sequence of challenging hardware modules that may perhaps perhaps lengthen the tool to be a barcode scanner or GPS tool. The add-on modules were both the essence and antithesis of convergence: They made the phone one thing more, however in far fewer programs and with far greater friction than apps would quickly enact.

Finest as Classic Magic became performed in by its blind spots, its inability to explore the vitality of a pure touchscreen tool with an infinite apps universe would imply the finish finish for Palm, BlackBerry and Microsoft’s mobile effort. And by 2008, when both the iPhone and Android had arrived with those attributes, 3G data, amazing cameras and cloud computing were highly efficient winds at their backs.

Donna Dubinsky

Donna Dubinksy co-founded Handspring and became CEO of Palm. She is for the time being CEO of Numenta.

Angela Lang/CNET

the remaining of the narrative: The iPhone went on to create the most important firm on this planet, and Android done 80% of a market that is since grown to three billion customers. So what’s subsequent?

“The iPhone came from the iPod, it wasn’t from Home windows Phone, Treo or Blackberry,” Fadell stated. “These were corporate, corporate, corporate. Nonetheless the iPhone became born of a varied web site of machine and hardware, versus all americans else who became making an are trying to construct a Home windows machine smaller.”

AR and properly being need convergence breakthroughs

Compaq iPaq with a BackPaq

No longer barely convergence: The Compaq iPaq handheld had a BackPaq add-on camera module.

HP Labs

The recipe for convergence success became properly acknowledged in a 2008 CNET column by tech alternate exec and consultant Steve Tobak: mental capital, drawl material and grand marketing. With little tuning, those are aloof the attach you would watch the following broad part in tech convergence.

That recipe may perhaps perhaps be no greater applied than to properly being and wellness convergence, raised in urgency by the COVID-19 pandemic. Abilities that may perhaps measure our properly being is all over us, from biometric wearables to trim audio system that may perhaps detect nuances of our being, facial recognition cameras and even millimeter wave radar that may perhaps video display us from afar. Nonetheless they largely live a balkanized mess, with out a single platform or two that may perhaps create a cogent dashboard for us, our properly being care suppliers and payers. Our autos isn’t a century ahead of ourselves in that appreciate.

“We’re seeing it in properly being care, things that Apple and Google are doing, however the quandary that often comes up is privateness,” Fadell stated. “This could perhaps perhaps be a step-by-step progression as you peek the advantages while additionally plugging the holes that create downsides that may perhaps perhaps dismay off folks.”

Tony Fadell

Tony Fadell led constructing of the iPod and loads of the iPhone ahead of founding Nest. This day he’s main at Future Form.

Stephen Shankland/CNET

One other solid candidate to jot down the following chapter of convergence may perhaps perhaps be augmented actuality, which is aloof making an are trying forward to its formidable promise to line up with a spend case that we are in a position to grok en masse. When, and if, AR can smash out of its contemporary Classic Magic-esque era, this may tightly map our digital world to our accurate one within the most sophisticated develop of convergence yet. Digital actuality takes the theme even deeper, however I mediate AR is at possibility of scale and may perhaps perhaps design its “iPhone 2nd” sooner. That step may perhaps perhaps even come from the iPhone maker itself.  

Convergence has matured from the engineering of mashups and miniaturization to the artwork of integration and human machine interface. Such integration leads us to more transparent and chronic tech, conserving convergence as vital to debate as ever.

Survey additionally: The handiest telephones for 2020